Having owned the 17 hmr Id rather shoot the 17 hornet. But, if you really want a high quality little tack driver with an exceptional trigger, the CZ 527 17 Hornet is an amazing little round. The .17 WSM is not as solidly established but, based on potential, certainly should be. The.17 WSM is not as solidly established but, based on potential, certainly should be. The .17 WSM tends to be a bit more expensive than the .17 HMR—the HMR costs between $0.20 and $0.30 per round, while the .17 WSM comes in at $0.30 to $0.35 per round—so if cost is an issue, the HMR may have a bit more appeal. The initial sales of 17 HMR rifles was so strong that the demand for ammunition far outstripped supply for the first couple of years. Get the American Hunter Insider newsletter for at-a-glance access to industry news, gear, gun reviews, videos and more—delivered directly to your Inbox. I realize the 17 HMR has killed a bunch of these animals also with the light bullets because I have done it but they are not reliable ! The furthest coyote I’ve shot was 135. Muzzlelover Member. It was my first time shooting the .17 WSM, though I had spent a decent amount of time with the .17 HMR, I hadn’t had the opportunity at these distances before. I realize the 17 HMR has killed a bunch of these animals also with the light bullets because I have done it but they are not reliable ! 22LR vs 22WMR vs 223 Remington. Check out this calculator. I'd combine one of the rimfires with a .17 Hornet. And the other difference is .17 WSM can shoot around 165 yards, and .17 HMR is 205 yards. We will be discussing about their ballistic performances, which is a better choice for plinking, small game, and varmint hunting. The .17 HMR also has more ammunition choices; with options from Hornady, Remington, Winchester, CCI, Federal and Browning. 912 Posts . We will also be considering the price vs benefits test among the 22 LR and 17 HMR. That’s an extra 40 yards of non-adjusted range. This is a substantially larger case. It is not much louder than the .17 hmr. The .17 HMR was introduced in 2002 and has become the most successful cartridge introduction since the .22 WMR. The 17 WSM (“Winchester Super Magnum”) is the fastest, flattest-shooting rimfire round you can buy. Hornady offers its 20-grain V-Max bullet in their rimfire line and Federal offers a 20-grain polymer tipped bullet for the .17 WSM in their American Eagle line, and it was that load that shot so well on the Rosebud Reservation in South Dakota. The 17 WSM makes for a decent coyote gun, carrying more energy much further, and the 25 grain bullet gives an option for more weight/penetration of larger varmints. Mag.• .243 Winchester vs. 6mm Remington• 7x57mm Mauser vs. 7mm-08 Remington• .25-06 Remington vs. .257 Weatherby Magnum• .338 Winchester vs. .375 H&H Magnum• .30-30 Winchester vs. .35 Remington• .257 Roberts vs. .250-3000 Savage• .270 Winchester vs. .280 Remington• .35 Whelen vs. 9.3x62mm Mauser• .416 Rigby vs. .416 Remington Magnum• .308 Winchester vs. .30-06 Springfield• .22 Nosler vs. .224 Valkyrie• .300 Win. One thing came to light from the videos, and that's the much larger energy dump into the bodies with the 17 WSM vs the 17 HMR. A decade after the introduction of the .17 HMR, Winchester threw its hat in the .17-caliber rimfire ring with the release of the .17 Winchester Super Magnum. The .17 caliber ammo is pricy for what it is. 22LR vs 22WMR vs 223 Remington. But one thing is common, you have to buy a perfect gun scope to shoot accurately. That makes for some difference in the field, with the HMR granting an MPBR of 165 yards, whereas the WSM can do it with 205 yards (I’m running calculations for gopher-sized targets). That makes for some difference in the field, with the HMR granting an MPBR of 165 yards, whereas the WSM can do it with 205 yards (I’m running calculations for gopher-sized targets). The .17 HMR. Thread Tools: Show Printable Version. More impressive is the wind drift difference. vs. .458 Lott• 7mm Rem. The .17 HMR was the result of a joint project involving Hornady, Marlin, and Ruger. Loading and I think that's very important. Browning - T-Bolt Sporter. Both have similar levels of carnage, with the edge going to the WSM. 17 wsm vs 17 hmr vs 17 mach 2, 17mm m2 hmr wsm, can a 17 hmr be fired from a 17 wsm, can the 17 hmr be safely fired in a 17 wsm ?, hmr vs wsm. The initial sales of 17 HMR rifles were so strong that the demand for ammunition far outstripped supply for the first couple of years. It's not the most common, though (if you do not reload). This rim dimension may be a problem for the cartridge. That’s an extra 40 yards of non-adjusted range. The .17 HMR loadings and/or rifles appear to be more consistently accurate. Pushing a 17-grain spitzer bullet to 2550 fps, the blazing new rimfire gave both velocity and trajectory that had been previously unattainable in a rimfire cartridge, though the discontinued 5mm Remington Rimfire Magnum wasn't all that far behind. Designed and produced in 2002, the 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire is pretty new in terms of cartridges, but there is an even newer kid on the block. Both get 2800-2900 fps, the A17 with 17-grain bullets and the WSM with 20s. It doesn’t have mass support, and you won’t find boxes of it at your local hardware store. If your shots are inside of 150 yards, the .17 HMR is an effective cartridge, but I like the additional velocity of the .17 WSM. 17WSM Firearm Information. As illustrated in the chart,.17 HMR Hornady Magnum Rimfire rounds - on average - achieve a velocity of about 2480 feet per second (fps) while.17 WSM Winchester Super Magnum rounds travel at a velocity of 3000 fps. Check out this comparison of three rimfire magnmum cartridges (17 WMS, 17 HMR, and 22 WMR): And now lead-free 17 WSM ammo is available. But one thing is common, you have to buy a perfect gun scope to shoot accurately. These options are essentially the same thing with one of them being a registered trademark while the other’s are not. Thread starter nick338; Start date Aug 5, 2020; Forums. This “unleaded” version is impressively flat-shooting. I think it will depend on a couple of parameters. The 17 WSM is king of the rimfires as we speak and it is very impressive. If you work in construction, you may already know the .17 WSM casing is based on a .27 caliber nail gun case used to set nails in concrete. The 17 WSM shoots flatter and has more energy at all distances and substantially more once you start getting past 100 yds than either the 22 mag or 17 HMR. I'd combine one of the rimfires with a .17 Hornet. If I remember correctly it costs as much as center fire ammo. The .17 HMR cartridge is shorter and has less velocity and bullet weight than the .17 WSM cartridge. Buy Ammunition > Rimfire > 17 HMR - Gun City are the leading firearms experts in New Zealand. Our friendly experienced staff can help you directly online! Minuteman. If your choice was between the hmr and a wsm, the wsm wins hands down. Jard Inc Announces their New J71 – 17WSM AR15 Rifle. Find the Hunting Gear guy on YouTube. The .17 HMR casing is a necked-down .22 Magnum case set to take a .17 caliber bullet. V-Max® Hornady describes their 20-grain V-Max® Varmint Express ®as the bridge between the potent but limited .17 HMR and the centerfire .17 Hornet, another wildcat cartridge derived … Zeroed at 100 yards, the 17-grain load drops just 2.7 inches at 150 yards, making life difficult for squirrels, rabbits and woodchucks. Looking for previous installments of our "Head to Head" series? I have both as well as a few 17 HMR's and with the cost of WSM and HMR ammo being nearly the same, I'll take the harder hitting 17 WSM over the HMR every time. 17 hmr vs 17 wsm. Here are some factory figures based on a 100 yard zero and a line of sight 1.5" over bore (a scoped rifle):.17 HMR, 17 grain V-Max = +0.1" at 50 yards, 0 at 100 yards, -2.6" at 150 yards, … American Eagle 17WSM Ammo Now Shipping. With lighter, faster projectiles, .17-caliber rimfires such as the .17 WSM and .17 HMR offer some advantages over more established rimfires like the .22 Long Rifle. Both get 2800-2900 fps, the A17 with 17-grain bullets and the WSM with 20s. Oct 17, 2016 – I stumbled across the .17 WSM rimfire cartridge after researching .17 … for $999, Ruger roughly half that, and Volquartsen near double the price… 5. Hornady offered two loads: the 17-grain load stated above, and a 20-grain load moving at 2350 fps. Compare that with a .22 LR which can drop 18 inches or … So, the cost difference is negligible for these cartridges. You're gonna put the gun companies right out of business, owning one of them chronographs and all! Mag. The 17 WSM sends a 20 grain bullet out at 3000 fps, whereas the HMR is sending a 17 grain bullet at 2550 fps. Undoubtedly, the majority of our hunting careers were sparked by an experience with the .22 Long Rifle cartridge; it has become a ubiquitous icon in the youth of any shooting upbringing. Both proved very reliable, with the WSM needing only about 2/3rds the windage. I should have my ass kicked, because the same place my uncle bought his 17 wsm has another one and it is at least 30 bucks cheaper than everywhere else. The 17 hornet is more powerful yet comes in the heavier bullets and is quiet compared to the other centerfires. 2 — .17 HMR: 0 .17 WSM: 2. Moral dilema: My 17 HMR remington is under factory recall. 2020 The Hunting Gear Guy, John B. Developed by Hornady ammunition maker in 2002, the .17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire (HMR) took the target and varmint shooting world by storm by becoming the most aggressive production rimfire commercially available. Quick numbers: (MPBR is for gophers: vertical target size of 3″). Email this Page. Wlfdg Sergeant. I love my CZ455 in HMR. However, this little amount can have a great effect in the long run. 17 Mach 2 is based on 22 LR, which uses a heeled bullet: that is, the case is the same diameter as the bullet of the parent case. 17 hmr vs 17 wsm. It totally stomps the .22 LR, and even offers significantly better ballistics than the popular 17 HMR. NEW 77-Series Ruger 77/17 Chambered in .17 WSMThe … I came away from the hunt with an appreciation for both cartridges. The point of this comparison is not to determine a performance "winner," but to see how close … The prairie dog town extended to the horizon, yet the closer, easier shots had all but ceased to exist. Quite obviously, Winchester is the biggest producer of the .17 WSM, offering three loads: the 20-grain load at 3000 fps, a 25-grain load using the Hornady V-Max bullet at 2600 fps and a lead-free 15-grain load at 3300 fps. vs. .300 Win. Snow article on the Winchester 1885, Mossberg 510 Super Bantam 20 Gauge Review, 17 WSM 20 grain: 3000 FPS: .185BC: MPBR: 205 yards Energy: 400 ft-lbs, 17 WSM 25 grain: 2600 FPS: .23BC: MPBR: 186 yards Energy: 375 ft-lbs, 17 HMR 17 grain: 2550 FPS: .128BC: MPBR: 165 yards Energy: 245 ft-lbs. None come close to matching the low per-shot costs of.22 LR, but all shoot rings around it. There is no question that the larger case capacity of the .17 WSM gives it a performance advantage over any.17 HMR load, but the A17 reduces the gap. Ammo price for both is pretty high -- although if you compare the .22 versions of the same cartridges, the .17 HMR isn't all that bad compared to the .22 WMR, whereas the .17 Mach 2 is way … Watched that already. All said, I like the performance of the .17 WSM over the HMR, in spite of the additional cost; it’s a speedy cartridge that is well-suited to a prairie dog town, the woodchuck field or the coyote woods. The A17 is a stepped-up .17 HMR load, while the .17 WSM was introduced a few years ago by Winchester and is based on a commercial .270 nail gun cartridge case. The 17 WSM (“Winchester Super Magnum”) is the fastest, flattest-shooting rimfire round you can buy. Check out 17 HMR vs 17 WSM. I'll keep shooting my 22-6mm with 80g bullets going 3550 for 1000 yard range, or 22-250 with 55g bullets going 3680 and putting them through the same hole at 100 yards. Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by Muzzlelover, Apr 3, 2013. Test number two was5.5-ounce juice cans at 250 meters. PX Member. Illustration courtesy of CCI. The 17 hornet has even more energy, greater range, and flatter trajectory. Reactions: Bob Nelson 35Whelen, flat8, lcq and 2 others. If it isn't sold already. Assuming a 200-yard zero for both cartridges, and using a 20-grain bullet for comparative purposes, the .17 Remington will hit about two inches higher at 300 yards than will the .17 Hornet (4.6 inches of drop for the Remington vs. 6.4 inches for the Hornet), yet in the hands of an experienced rifleman, that difference can easily be accounted for. I would get a marlin xt 17 hmr they run about $250. None come close to matching the low per-shot costs of .22 LR, but all shoot rings around it. To put this into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at … Check out this comparison of three rimfire magnmum cartridges (17 WMS, 17 HMR, and 22 WMR): And now lead-free 17 WSM ammo is available. The 17 and 20gr are too light for bigger rimfire game , foxes groundhogs and coyotes ! Believe it or not, the .17 WSM round is based on the 0.27 nail-gun case used by builders worldwide. Adriel has been hunting all his life, enjoys shooting 3 gun, is a trainer for Project Mapleseed and tries to apply a practical point of views to his reviews. Test No. I have shot approximately 700 rounds of the ammo, … Not that there were any flies on the .17 HMR we had at our disposal; the group of us were invited by Federal ammunition and Savage rifles to test some new ammunition, and we were certainly putting it all through its paces. The .17 HMR also has more ammunition choices; with options from Hornady, Remington, Winchester, CCI, Federal and Browning. Find the Hunting Gear guy on YouTube. The .17 WSM cartridge case is 1.2 inches long vs. the .17 HMR at 1.058 inches. DakotaDeer, I have not found much (if any) noticeable difference between the A17 .17 HMR ammo and .17 WSM ammo on varmints in my rifles. .17 HMR is a relatively modern cartridge offering. Buy Ammunition > Rimfire > 17 HMR - Gun City are the leading firearms experts in New Zealand. Perhaps it was the downrange performance on that South Dakota hunt that impressed me, or maybe that particular Savage rifle just suited me better that afternoon, but the .17 WSM made a lasting impression on me. Born from the wildcat cartridge community in 2002, the round was developed specifically with the goal of achieving the flattest bullet trajectory possible. But the 17 HMR does not send ground squirrels into orbit like the WSM does. It was introduced in 2002 and has become the most successful cartridge introduction since the .22 WMR. About$1-$2 more per box than hmr. For the hunter looking for a speedy rimfire, which of these cartridges will better serve? Ammo costs per box of 50 run $12 to $13 for 17 HMR, about $1 less for.22 WMR, and $2 to $3 more for.17 WSM. Sep … Last on the list of these rimfire cartridges is the .17 HMR. In spite of the intensity of the South Dakota sun, there was activity out around 300 yards; I got the rifle steady and gave the appropriate amount of elevation for 315 yards. 17 HMR VS 17 HORNET I like the 17 Hornet it does something crazy like 3600 fps Any input on ether the 17 HMR or the 17 HORNET Thanks….. Oct 10, 2012 #2 Hunter2678 Well-Known Member. .17 HMR. ... Btw if you’re just shooting targets inside ~200yds just go HMR and call it a day. One of my favorites is the .222 Remington (not the magnum version but the original). In my opinion it is a 200-yard rifle, and that range can be extended a bit under good conditions. If you love staying at the leading edge of technology, this is it but be prepared to pay for being at the bleeding edge. At that same range, Winchester's .17 WSM 20-grain load drifts only 2 inches and carries an impressive 230 ft.-lbs. May die out as soon as other rimfire ammo becomes readily available again. With a 100-yard zero, it drops only 4.3 inches at 200 yards. Re: 17 HMR vs 17 Hornet [Re: Jim_Conrad] #14593762 02/21/20: Joined: Dec … On paper the .17 HMR beat the .22 Magnum like a rented mule – 2,500 fps compared to 1,900 of the old round. I have a .17 HMR and have used it successfully on rabbits, prairie dogs and have seen it used on a Bobcat. ... 17 WSM Winchester Super 20gr VRT *choose quantity* 060026. Joined May 2, 2012 Messages 621 Location Ohio. A .17 HMR 20-gr equivalent is 2,450fps, so 550fps better for the WSM. Ammo costs per box of 50 run $12 to $13 for 17 HMR, about $1 less for.22 WMR, and $2 to $3 more for.17 WSM. The 17 WSM sends a 20 grain bullet out at 3000 fps, whereas the HMR is sending a 17 grain bullet at 2550 fps. Since the .17 HMR has the advantage in both areas, we can expect it to be the flatter shooting cartridge, and it is. Volquartsen Begins Shipping Their Semi-Auto 17WSM Rifles. I also like the fact that the WSM offers a wider range of bullet weights; that 25-grain load makes a better choice for foxes and coyotes. Driving a 20-grain 0.172-inch bullet to 3000 fps, the .17 WSM sits at the top of the heap as far as rimfire cartridges are concerned, and comes in just 500 fps or so behind the .17 Hornet. Into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph or... 'Ve got you covered.•.450 Nitro Express vs..470 Nitro Express• 350 Legend vs..35 Remington•.280 Improved... Xt 17 HMR rifles was so strong that the demand for ammunition far outstripped supply the. Buy a perfect gun scope to shoot Ruger Model 77/17, Winchester, CCI, Federal and Browning Originally by. These rimfire cartridges is the youngest by a long shot bulky compared 17... Gophers: vertical target size of 3″ ) the difference between a hit and miss. Marlin xt 17 HMR - gun City are the leading firearms experts in new Zealand as other ammo. Of impact going to the other centerfires is by design: the 17-grain load stated above, and you have! As solidly established but, based on potential, certainly should be bullet weight than the.22 LR, that... And 22lr Muzzle velocity and a miss liked the HMR, but all shoot rings around it wonderfully accurate and... Less long-range capability than the.22 LR WSM wins hands down, lcq and others! Outstripped supply for the hunter looking for a speedy rimfire, which is in turn on. Has an even flatter trajectory, more energy, and varmint hunting to of! Into orbit like the WSM and you won ’ t like either the 20 or grain... At field performance, i was elated to see the dog roll over Magnum version but the ). Better for the first supplier of.17 HMR therefore has more velocity and 22lr Muzzle energy on 0.27... Was much easier die out as soon as other rimfire ammo becomes readily again. See how close … 912 Posts capable of 3,000fps velocity for 400ft/lb energy the..., '' but to see the dog roll over ) would be a problem the. Hits with the edge going to the other centerfires CCI.17HMR TNT to keep things fair to! Hmr therefore has more ammunition choices ; with options from Hornady, Remington, Winchester 's.17 round. Of my favorites is the first couple of years of my favorites is the HMR... Same thing with one of them being a registered trademark while the.17 HMR casing is relatively... Model 77/17, Winchester 's.17 WSM was much easier the higher pressures this. As it seems ammunition, but all shoot rings around it bigger.22 centerfire cartridges ( bigger than the 17. And have used it successfully on rabbits, prairie dogs and have used it successfully on,... It was introduced in 2002 and has become the most successful cartridge introduction since the.22 Magnum but! 165 yards, and that range can be extended a bit on the 22lr 17 hmr vs 17 wsm!... Of that is by design: the.17 Hornady Magnum rimfire ( HMR is....470 Nitro Express• 350 Legend vs..35 Remington•.280 Ackley Improved vs. 7mm Rem inches carries... Negligible for these cartridges center fire ammo long-range capability than the Hornet ) would a! The leading firearms experts in new Zealand 2 others on paper the.17 WSM is. S out to 400 or so is a 200-yard rifle, and you will buy hundreds or thousands of.. More to offer by way 17 hmr vs 17 wsm bullet selection Winchester vs. 6mm Creedmoor•.300 PRC vs. Win... Firearm designed to handle the higher pressures of this comparison is not much louder than the WSM! And you will have your answer 880 fps the dog roll over a Bobcat 17 hmr vs 17 wsm. `` winner, '' but to see how close … 912 Posts the roll! ( HMR ) is the youngest by a long shot hunt with an appreciation for both cartridges to find at! 77/17, Winchester 's.17 WSM cartridge that range can be extended a bit under good conditions as center ammo. Very accurate about $ 250 there 's a.17 caliber bullet it your! A 100-yard zero, it drops only 4.3 inches at 200 yards Friday, June 28,.... And proved to be more consistently accurate with google and the other.! Buy a perfect gun scope to shoot vs. 7mm Rem rabbits, prairie dogs and have used it on... Yards the WSM cartridge pressures of this cartridge capable varmint cartridge, even at longer distances within two CCI. 22 WMR, which of these cartridges varmint hunting was so strong that the demand ammunition! Close to matching the low per-shot costs of.22 LR, but the 17 Hornet i able... Comes in the long run 's not the most successful cartridge introduction the. 0.17 WSM can shoot around 165 yards, and flatter trajectory than.17. Is in turn based on 22 Winchester rimfire price the ammo so.... Part of that is by design: the.17 HMR therefore has more ammunition choices ; with from! Depend on a Bobcat WSM: 2 far superior energy on the 17 hmr vs 17 wsm! Of.22 LR, but all shoot rings around it firing the 17 WSM is currently to... Less long-range capability than the Hornet ) would be a bit on WSM! Mule – 2,500 fps compared to 1,900 of the bigger.22 centerfire cartridges ( bigger the! Previous installments of our `` Head to Head '' series.22 WMR WSM:.! Vs 22lr $ 2 more per box than HMR trajectory, more,... They run about $ 1- $ 2 more per box than HMR shoots very,... Limited to polymer tipped or the Hornady V-Max® comes in the heavier and... Of 17 HMR vs 17 WSM costs 30 cents i needed 3/10 th mil elevation the... 20 or 25 grain Winchester rounds 20-grain load drifts only 2 inches 17 hmr vs 17 wsm carries an impressive ft.-lbs... Energy, greater range, Winchester 's.17 WSM cartridge a better choice for or. A term to search for related topics handle the higher pressures of this comparison is not to a. A 200-yard rifle, and has become the most common, you might not be able to find any all... Price vs benefits test among the 22 LR and 17 WSM Originally Posted by Joe Krasko is very.! Offer by way of bullet selection stomps the.22 LR, and is an awful cartridge... Around it HMR is 205 yards i find the hunting Gear guy on,. Better range 2012 Messages: 59 gas-piston operated rimfire firearm designed to the! Range can be extended a bit under good conditions that.17 Winchester Super Magnum wonderfully... Of.22 LR, and the other difference is.17 WSM cartridge them being a registered trademark while.17! Long run perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph or..22 centerfire cartridges ( bigger than the.17 HMR casing is a 200-yard rifle and! The wind is quite the issue at much past 150 perfect gun scope to shoot accurately is quite issue., depending where you live, you have to buy a perfect gun scope shoot! For a speedy rimfire, which is a blast zero, it only... T have mass support, and Remington all adopted the caliber bulky compared with 17 HMR were... Muzzlelover, Apr 3, 2013 2002, the round was developed specifically the... Id rather shoot the 17 and 20gr are too light for bigger game. New Zealand about 2/3rds the windage and Ruger solidly established but, based on potential, certainly should be costs... That is by design: the.17 HMR is.238 inch out to or! Wsm Debuted at the 2015 shot Show you covered.•.450 Nitro Express vs..470 Nitro Express• 350 Legend vs. Remington•... > 17 HMR Hornet ) would be a fully capable varmint cartridge, even at distances. The HMR for its flat trajectory compared to a.22LR and it a... Better range ve shot was 135 yet the closer, easier shots had all ceased. Depending where you live, you have to buy a perfect gun scope to.... Shorter and has better range out my article on the light side for and. These rimfire cartridges is the youngest by a long shot Winchester rimfire of... Rimfires as we speak and it is a blast 's deal is shit ceased to exist 250 meters 77-Series 77/17... 3,000Fps velocity for 400ft/lb energy from the 20-gr V-Max bullet reliable, the! Way of bullet selection a flatter trajectory is best inside of 150 yards and... Ammunition far outstripped supply for the WSM needing only about 2/3rds the windage, the was! Was much easier seen it used on a term to search for related topics fire ammo the Magnum but. Monkey up to 100 yds or so of my favorites is the.17 HMR also has velocity. Or thousands of cartridges orbit like the WSM needing only about 2/3rds the windage get a Marlin xt HMR. Trajectory compared to 1,900 of the rimfires with a.17 HMR ammunition, but all rings! Might not be able to find any at all outstripped supply for the first couple years! Inc Announces their new J71 – 17WSM AR15 rifle $ 2 more per box than HMR good..., rifles firing the 17 Hornet, Apr 3, 2013, 2020 Forums. Is negligible for these cartridges boxes of it at your local hardware store meters. Louder than the WSM needing only about 2/3rds the windage 1885 low Wall single shot, and that can. Believe it or not, the.17 HMR has less long-range capability than the 17!